Streets and squares

Painting and decorating in Rutland Mews South

Rutland Mews South is the one place in this group where the appraisal says the painting has already happened. The mews has been almost completely painted, and the document calls that a regrettable part of its modern character rather than the original intention. A decorating brief here is therefore about maintaining a coating honestly, not about creating one.

Sources: Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, Brompton Conservation Area Appraisal

Built late, and built tight

The appraisal's key building dates place the building of Rutland Mews South in the 1850s. It was built on land that Elger bought from Batty in 1849 after Farlar's death, and the buildings were controversially put hard up against the rear elevations of the Rutland Street cottages, leaving neither with any garden or yard at all; one of those rear elevations can be seen on the left on entering the mews. Number 31 Rutland Street appears to have been built as part of the mews, as were numbers 2-4 Ennismore Gardens, although those were rebuilt after the First World War. The houses at 2-4 Ennismore Street stand on the site of stabling at the end of the mews.

That history explains the awkwardness of the place. The cottages at 11-29 Rutland Street are one room deep over two main floors and a half basement, and the mews is pressed against their backs. There is no buffer: a rear wall of one terrace faces the flank of another across very little space. Anyone planning work here needs to understand whose wall is whose before the first ladder goes up, because the two groups of buildings were deliberately built without gardens or yards between them.

Sources: Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, Brompton Conservation Area Appraisal

What the appraisal says about the paint

Among the alterations that harm the character of the conservation area, the appraisal lists painted masonry elevations where this was not the original intent, and it names this mews: Rutland Mews South has been almost completely painted, so that this has regrettably become part of its modern character, but this was not the original intent. It also records that the buildings have been much altered: rendered, painted, refenestrated and extended upwards so that they appear as houses rather than the stabling they originally were. That is a candid account of a mews that has been converted thoroughly.

For a decorator, the honest position follows from that. An existing coating on masonry is maintained as what it is. There is no case for extending paint onto any brickwork that has escaped it, because the appraisal has already described the painting as contrary to the original intent. Equally, there is no pretence that stripping a whole mews back to brick is a decorating job: that would be a substantial conservation project with its own risks, and the appraisal's own remedy for negative elements is phrased as something to pursue when opportunities arise, not as a condition of redecoration.

Sources: Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, Brompton Conservation Area Appraisal

What has survived, and what the alterations took

The appraisal is careful to say that some historic features remain and that these help retain the historic character of the group. Alongside them it lists the surface: setts that fall away to shallow gullies at both sides, and the lack of pavements or front areas and lightwells. Another characteristic is the slight change in the direction of the mews towards the south, which leaves some buildings stepped back, angled or with corners projecting, adding to the informal back-street charm. In the mews generally, metal up and over doors have replaced traditional timber coach doors, openings have been infilled, upper-floor windows have been lost or replaced with uPVC, and some buildings have been clad or rendered with smooth cement render.

A survey here is therefore a list of what each unit actually is: painted masonry, cement render, modern cladding, timber joinery, uPVC, metal doors. Those are five different items with five different treatments, and uPVC is excluded from a painting specification rather than coated. The angled and stepped-back buildings mean that no two fronts in the mews present the same face to the weather or to a ladder, so each is measured on its own.

Sources: Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, Brompton Conservation Area Appraisal

The surface underfoot is part of the designation

Triple rows of granite setts lead into the gulleys in Rutland Mews South, where the setts cover the whole of the mews surface. That is recorded in the appraisal's list of street surfaces worth keeping, and it is the reason access has to be planned rather than assumed. There are no pavements and no front areas, so protection goes straight onto a historic surface, and the gullies at both sides must keep running during the work. Sheets are weighted rather than fixed, washings are never tipped into a gully, and the surface is swept and checked at the end of each day.

Vehicles complicate a closed mews. Residents park where the trestles need to stand, deliveries arrive through a single entrance, and a structure that occupies the highway needs a licence, with a protective fan required where there is any risk of falling material reaching pedestrians or vehicles. Those conversations happen before the start date, with neighbours as well as with the council.

Sources: Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, Brompton Conservation Area Appraisal; Westminster City Council, Scaffolding (temporary structures guide)

How the work is approached on a converted mews

The method is ordinary trade practice applied to an unusual set of surfaces. Existing coatings are tested for adhesion and soundness, loose material is removed, edges are feathered and bare areas are primed before any finish. Cement render on an older brick building is examined for cracks and for trapped moisture rather than simply recoated; if damp is the reason a coating is being discussed, that is a defect question for someone to investigate before decoration. Joinery is prepared as joinery, metal doors as metal, and anything plastic is left out of the schedule and said to be left out.

Weather and light in a narrow mews are not what they are in a square. Buildings on both sides keep the elevations shaded, drying is slower, and a short run of good conditions is used for the coats that need it. Occupancy is close: the people living here have no front garden between their doors and the work, so each front is finished and cleared rather than left part-done.

Sources: Historic England: redecoration and historic finishes; Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, Brompton Conservation Area Appraisal

Consent and the one change to avoid

Ordinary painting of a house does not need planning permission, with listed buildings and Article 4 areas as the exceptions to check for the full address. This mews is in the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, inside the Brompton Conservation Area, so that is where the address check is made. Historic England's advice draws the line that matters here: like-for-like external redecoration, matching paint type, texture, finish and colour, usually sits outside listed building consent, while painting a currently unpainted surface is likely to need consent, and a change of finish usually would.

In practice that means a repaint of an already painted front is routine, and any proposal to take paint onto unpainted masonry, or to change the character of the finish, is checked first. Older films are treated as potentially leaded, so no blow lamps or gas torches, no dry sanding, and stripping limited to paint that is flaking, chipping or giving off dust. Where a textured coating is found it is never sanded or scraped through.

Sources: Planning Portal, External walls: planning permission; Historic England, Listed Building Consent (Historic England Advice Note 16); HSE, Construction hazardous substances: Lead; HSE, Old lead paint: what you need to know as a busy builder (CIS79); HSE Asbestos essentials a28, Removing textured coating from a small area

What drives the cost in this mews

The first factor is how many different surfaces one front carries, because painted masonry, cement render, cladding and joinery each need their own preparation. The second is the condition of the existing coating, which decides how much comes off. The third is access across protected setts with no pavement and resident parking. The fourth is the stepped and angled building line, which makes staging slower than a straight run. The fifth is any repair to render, rainwater goods or joinery, which is named separately. No figure appears on this page.

Because the mews is built hard against the Rutland Street cottages, work on a rear or flank elevation may need a neighbour's cooperation for access. That is identified at survey stage and written into the quotation as an assumption rather than discovered later.

The streets this mews was built behind

Rutland Street is the cottage terrace whose rear elevations the mews was built against. Ennismore Street holds the Tudor houses on the site of the old stabling. Relton Mews and Ennismore Gardens Mews are the nearby mews with published guidance.

Questions about Painting and decorating in Rutland Mews South

When was Rutland Mews South built?

The appraisal's key building dates place it in the 1850s, on land that Elger bought from Batty in 1849 after Farlar's death.

Is the painted masonry here acceptable?

The appraisal lists painted masonry elevations where this was not the original intent among the harmful alterations, and says Rutland Mews South has been almost completely painted so that this has regrettably become part of its modern character.

Why is there no pavement?

The mews was built without pavements, front areas or lightwells. Triple rows of granite setts lead into the gulleys and the setts cover the whole of the mews surface, which is recorded as part of its character.

What happened to the original stable openings and windows?

The buildings have been rendered, painted, refenestrated and extended upwards so that they appear as houses rather than the stabling they originally were. Across the mews generally, coach doors have been replaced with metal up and over doors and upper-floor windows have been lost or replaced with uPVC.

Arrange your decoration

Tell us about
the property.

A room, an entrance or the whole property: let us know the extent of the work you have in mind. Add the Knightsbridge address and any dates or building arrangements we should consider.

A note about your property

Include the rooms or outside surfaces, their condition and your priorities.

Read our privacy policy about how we handle your enquiry.